How to choose the right mascara for your lashes
A November morning: fog, drizzle, maybe a bike ride to work. Mid-morning you glance in the mirror and there it is, a grey shadow under your eyes that definitely wasn't there when you left home. Sound familiar? Then you already know that mascara isn't just "a little black tube" and that it really does matter which one you reach for.
One promises volume, another length, a third curled lashes, a fourth survives the rain. And the one that looks gorgeous on your friend's lashes prints onto your eyelid by lunchtime. So this time we're talking mascara: what the brush and the formula really do, what tubing mascara is, and which IDUN Minerals mascara could be the right one for you.
First, take a good look at your lashes (and lids)

Before you choose a mascara, look in the mirror in daylight, without any makeup. Are your lashes short or long, thick or sparse, straight or naturally curled? And an even more important question: does your lid touch your lashes when your eyes are open? With hooded lids, even a good mascara tends to print if the formula isn't right.
Short lashes need length above all, and a brush that catches them right at the root. Long lashes are a lovely base for volume. Sparse lashes will thank you for a creamy formula that "thickens" each lash a little, while thick lashes need good separation so they don't clump together. Very fair lashes can be defined softly with brown mascara, or boldly with black.
Brush or formula: which one matters?

Both! The same formula looks completely different with a different brush. A bristle brush with dense, soft fibres picks up more mascara and lays it on in a thicker coat, which makes it volume's best friend. A rubber brush has fewer, flexible bristles that comb through each lash separately. It gives you separated, longer lashes without clumps, and because it's slimmer, it's easier to reach the corners and lower lashes.
The formula decides how long your mascara stays where you put it. Classic mascara comes off with a cleansing lotion or makeup remover. Waterproof mascara stands up to water and tears, but often needs a fair bit of rubbing to remove, and the delicate skin around your eyes isn't a fan of that. And then there's a third option that many people still haven't discovered.
Does your mascara print onto your lid? Meet tubing

Tubing mascara forms a tiny, flexible tube around each lash. Once dry, it stands up to water, sweat, tears and humidity, so it doesn't smudge or flake. The best part is removal: no rubbing and no remover, just warm water at around 38 °C. The tubes soften and simply slide off your lashes. You'll see tiny dark "rolls" on your fingers, and that's completely normal.
Personally, I have fine but long lashes and hooded lids, so mascara usually prints around my eyes quickly. Testing the Vatn Volume 38 °C tubing mascara was a real pleasure! Right after applying, it does exactly what it promises: volume, with no clumps and no mess. It doesn't smudge during the day or leave black marks on my lids, and in the evening I simply rinse my lashes with warm water and the little tubes come right off.
Vatn Volume has a soft rubber brush, its formula contains shea butter and castor oil, and IDUN describes it as vegan and ophthalmologically tested. Besides black, it comes in brown and royal blue, and as a 3.5 ml mini that's wonderfully handy for your handbag or suitcase. My tip for the blue: apply black mascara first, then add the blue just at the corners over the black. A play of colour that really opens up your eyes!
For a more natural look there's Vatn Waterproof 38 °C mascara with a slim rubber brush. I warmly recommend it for hooded lids, short and straight lashes, and eyes that water easily. If you cycle to work and your eyes water on the way, this is the mascara for you. In fog and rain it doesn't melt, flake or print. But honestly: Vatn isn't a mascara for big volume. Because it dries quickly, it won't take several coats, and your lashes may clump.
Two more things worth knowing. Tubing mascara dries quickly, so finish one eye completely before moving on to the other, and add a second coat while the first is still fresh. And since warm water removes it, it won't last in a hot bath or a thermal spa.
Volume, length or everything in one?

If your lids behave, you have even more choice. For dark, eye-catching volume there's Magna mascara, which I always keep one of "in stock". Its rich, creamy texture coats the lashes instantly and gives them that real wow volume, with no clumps and no heavy feeling. For even more impact, wait until the first coat is at least partly dry, then apply a second.
Eir mascara has a large oval brush and a creamy texture that coats the lashes without weighing them down, so you can build it from a daytime look to a very full one. Gull mascara is a classic with a bristle brush that combs the lashes nicely and defines them naturally, for work and every day. Because the brush is a little larger, swap it for Vatn Volume if you have hooded lids.
Do you have short or straight lashes? Try Magna Lengthening mascara. Its narrow, small brush catches even the shortest lashes in the inner corner without smudging your lid. The texture is quite wet, so give it a moment to dry. Silfr mascara, with tapered rubber bristles, lengthens and beautifully separates the lashes. When I used it, you could really see its WOW effect: completely natural, yet your eyes look rested and polished even without other makeup. If you're not used to mascara, don't be afraid of brown Silfr. It's dark enough to define your lashes and soft at the same time.
Would you like just one mascara for everything? Liv mascara has short and long bristles on its rubber brush, so you can lengthen your lashes with one side and add volume with the other. Whether it will also curl your lashes, I honestly can't say, as mine are naturally curled. If you try it, let me know!
- Hooded lids or watery eyes: Vatn Volume or Vatn Waterproof.
- Short, straight lashes: Magna Lengthening or Silfr.
- Full, dark volume: Magna or Eir.
- A natural everyday look: Gull or brown Silfr.
- Length and volume in one tube: Liv.
How to apply mascara so it looks lovely

Start with clean, dry lashes, because mascara doesn't grip well on traces of cream or oil. If you curl your lashes, do it before applying mascara, never after. Wipe off excess mascara on the rim of the tube, and don't pump the brush in and out, as that pushes air into the tube and dries the mascara out faster.
Place the brush right at the root of your lashes, wiggle it from side to side a few times, then pull it through to the tips. Add coats while the mascara is still wet and you won't get clumps. For the lower lashes, hold the brush vertically and use just the tip, with a single gentle stroke.
Remove classic mascara in the evening with IDUN cleansing lotion for face and eyes: moisten a cotton pad, hold it on your closed eye for a few seconds, then gently wipe the mascara away. Be extra gentle around the eyes. For tubing mascaras, warm water is all you need.
And let's not forget: replace your mascara every few months (the packaging tells you how many months after opening to use it up) and don't share it. If your eyes sting or you notice redness, stop using it, and if the problem doesn't go away, talk to a doctor or pharmacist.
The right mascara is the one you forget about during the day, because it doesn't print, flake or clump. You'll find all IDUN Minerals mascaras in our Mascaras category, and if dry winter air is bothering you, read how to help your skin through winter. Not sure which one is right for you? Write to us, we're happy to help!
Recommended in the article
-
IDUN Minerals Vatn Volume 38°C Tubing Mascara Black 9 ml – IDUN Minerals
€19.20
-
IDUN Minerals Mascara Vatn – IDUN Minerals
€19.20
-
IDUN Minerals Magna Volume Mascara – IDUN Minerals
€20.80
-
IDUN Minerals Magna Lengthening Mascara – IDUN Minerals
€20.80
-
IDUN Minerals Mascara Silfr Black – IDUN Minerals
€19.20
-
IDUN Minerals LIV Mascara Limited Edition 12.5 ml – IDUN Minerals
€20.80
-
IDUN Minerals Mascara Eir – IDUN Minerals
€20.80
-
IDUN Minerals Mascara Gull 11.5 ml – IDUN Minerals
€14.40